Hogs Haven: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: June USA Today / SB Nation Consensus MMA Rankings Released


Awfully needy 9-7 team

Matt Williamson at ESPN writes: Redskins have a new head coach and lots of draft needs. The title shouted at me, since I was of the opinion that we didn't have that many serious needs, as we have in years past. But, to Williamson's credit, I think he does a fine job of explaining just where the team is at and where it isn't, even if the title perhaps overstates the case. He says...

Washington could go a lot of different ways with its early draft selections. However, that is both good and bad. The Redskins are not pigeon-holed into one glaring position of need so that should allow them to take the best athlete available, but that also is a sign that Washington could use help in a lot of areas. Washington could use a safety, line help and probably another cornerback on defense. They could also use offensive line depth and a big wide receiver, which is probably their most prominent need if we had to choose just one. The other obvious remaining question is how Zorn will handle his new duties.
Reed Doughty will know where he stands with the coaching staff by draft day 2; if we haven't selected a safety by then, it's a good bet he'll end up the unchallenged starter heading into 2008. I remain convinced, though, that Doughty overachieved his way into Gregg Williams' heart and question whether a new HC is willing to take a chance on a 6th round pick out of Northern Colorado. The good news for Doughty is that new Redskins D-Coordinator Greg Blache has been with the team for the past four years and thus is more inclined to keep personnel around than if, say, Zorn had brought in his own guys. Blache knows Reed Doughty.

Everyone could use line help. By the metrics I care about, the Redskins were mediocre last year. Our adjusted sack rate of 5.7% was lower than the league average (6.4%). This was still a marked improvement over 2006 and there is reason for optimism. Andre Carter appears to have found himself once more in Washington, and we've developed some young defensive tackles in Anthony Montgomery and Kedric Golston, who should both improve over time. Also, Chris Wilson emerged as a pass rushing threat with 4 sacks on the season and two mas in our playoff loss. The bad news is that Phillip Daniels and Cornelius Griffin aren't getting any younger and need replacing sooner rather than later. I have more confidence that Kedric the Barbarian can be a full time defensive tackle than I do that Chris Wilson can do same for Phillip Daniels (based only on the sample size; I know more about Golston) and so I tentatively lean towards drafting a DE over a DT. Also, Daniels is 3 years older than Griffin. Another reason to suspect we'll go defensive line as opposed to another position is that Greg Blache was formerly the line coach, and he understands the needs of that position more than anyone else on staff.

Offensive line depth is a no brainer, even as we just resigned Jason Fabini. That unit is old by old standards, and five positions cannot be filled by Stephon Heyer and Lorenzo Alexander, even thought he latter is the definition of a football utility player. At some point we're going to have to start drafting offensive linemen and, more importantly than that, they're going to have to start sticking. That means less Kili Lefotu, less Mark Wilson, less Jim Molinaro, more Derrick Dockery. (Draft history.)

Another cornerback could be a good direction given injuries to Carlos Rogers and Shawn Springs' age, though I don't know if that's something I'd address in the first two rounds. Just my opinion, though.

On to the Big Wide Receiver. You guys already own this discussion in this diary, raising all the points I would and then some. If we're sold on WR and Defensive Line, the question is how best to exercise a draft day one-two punch. Do we go...:

Malcolm Kelly / Calais Campbell first two picks better than a Harvey / whoever draft?
The alternative is that we go big wide receiver after the first two, a strategy I wouldn't mind especially given my perhaps irrational faith in Anthony Mix to emerge as that role player. If all we want is a large body to move chains not farther than 7-8 yards from scrimmage, can we not get that guy in later rounds?

That said, I am not opposed to drafting a wide receiver early on (2nd round!). As the SB Nation Mock Draft is quickly approaching, I'm using this opportunity to solicit you, reader(s), for advice on who to draft. I want Hogs Haven's pick to be community decided, as it is apparent you all know more about the draft than I do. I'm simply not a draft guru. X+1 heads > X heads.

0 recs | Comment 7 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Why does the National Media
always hate on the Redskins? I never hear anything positive from them. Well that just grinds my gears!

I posted what I thought would be nice to do in this upcomming draft in the previous post. I don't expect anything else to change in the teams thought process.

The draft really needs to hurry the fuck up and get here already

by CptChaosSidekick on Mar 25, 2008 2:07 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

The good and the bad.
I tend to agree with the national media being down on the Redskins, but have you noticed that even though the Redskins were made fun of during and after Danny's big spending the Prognosticators seemed to pick the Redskins to do well.  In 2006, talk at the start of the year was a for sure playoff team and possibly the class of the NFC.  
The Good!
When everyone tends to treat the Redskins as underperforms, who has to address a lot of needs, a new coach, etc.  Are the years the Redskins tend to do the best.  2008 should be a great year.

by dr WNC on Mar 25, 2008 5:25 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

My thoughts...
For me, two players with a slim chance to fall to the Skins are Derrick Harvey and Aqib Talib. I don't think they will, but if they do you have to take them.

Barring a few surprise picks, we are probably looking at five players. A very strong case can be made for pick any of these guys...what makes it hard for us is that a strong case can be made against picking them as well.

Limas Sweed
Philip Merling
Devin Thomas
Kenny Philips
Calais Campbell

You can make a really good case for any of these players. A dark horse in this group is Kenny Philips. I agree that Reed probably over-achieved last season and I doubt that he has  convinced anyone that he can hold that position down consistently next season. If you look at the draft, the most likely position to find superior talent in round two is DE. The same can be said about receivers in round three. Don't be surprised to see us take another Hurricane to play along side Landry in the first round.

Personally, I think we will/should take Sweed with our pick if possible. I think this pick is going to be all Jim Zorn, a welcoming gift of sorts. He picks the guy that completes his receiving corps.

In the second round, I think we need to do whatever it takes to get Lawrence Jackson.

So if Harvey or Talib are there, get 'em. If not, I say pick up Sweed.
 

by Romans12 on Mar 25, 2008 3:51 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Are you down on Malcolm Kelly...
or is he in the group that "doesn't fall" to pick 21?

by TexSkins on Mar 25, 2008 6:14 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

I like Kelly....
I just dont think he is going to be there unless all of the injury talk kills his stock. I'd be surprised if Buffalo and Philly pass on him.

Both Sweed and Kelly seem pretty equal to me. I'm not sure, however, how well Limas Sweed can freestyle.

by Romans12 on Mar 25, 2008 7:37 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Ok! here's what I dont get.
Over at ESPN sportsnation
a [http://sports.espn.go.com/chat/sportsnation/story?page=snmock08#dolphins]

Choices are:
Derrick Harvey, DE
 Mario Manningham, WR
 Leodis McKelvin, CB
 Kenny Phillips, S
 Chris Williams, OT
And so far...Mario is in the lead, with Derrick Harvey a far third behind Phillips.
As described needs can be discussed at many positions but overall value is so much more clear.
This is a position where "fans" get to involved with a position "need" instead of VALUE
Per Scout.com and NFL Draft count down: overall rankings of players
Phillips: #24 and #15
Mckelvin: #13 and #13
Harvey: : #12 and #19
Williams: #10 and #26
MARIO: #30 and #41
Please Justify how he becomes the better pick when the others are available and "better players"...My pick Harvey based on more need than CB and S.

by dr WNC on Mar 25, 2008 6:40 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

If you look at the entire mock...
you will realize that it's worthless.

It does provide a reminder that anything can happen, and also offer some insight on what surprise picks may occur. For instance, what if Buffalo does takes Kelly and then Denver takes Sweed to fill in Javon Walker's spot (especially now that Brandon Marshall is out for a few months).

Although it is unlikely to happen, all it takes is one person to fall in love with a player.

If the draft follows this mock, I can't complain. For Harvey to fall into our laps without any maneuvering would be a miracle. I'll take it.

by Romans12 on Mar 25, 2008 7:50 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Please imagine that this is something witty, moving, or insightful.
Start posting about the Redskins »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Current Undrafted Offensive Linemen
Eagles_small
Could Colt Brennan be the future?
Ron_mexico_2-343x240_small
Home Jerseys
Redskins_cheerleader_small
Lead the league in 3 and outs
Small
Orakpo at LB, Pt. 2
Small
One Half Second Longer
Small
Brian Orakpo at LB
Small
a mystery jersey
Sean-taylor-boom-king_small
Haynesworth Was Offered More Money From Tampa
183_small
Finally off the Season Ticket Waiting List !

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

SPONSORS


Managers

Superbowl_small KevinE

Riggins_small sugar

Authors

Hogshaven_small Skin Patrol

Gadsden_small DbacksSkins

Official Partner of Yahoo! Sports