So, when compared to Luck's evaluation:
National Football Post: Washington had to pay a pretty penny, but it got its QB of the future. RG3 is an ideal fit for Washington's offense with his ability to be effective in the boot-action game and create big plays down the field with his arm and legs outside the pocket. NFL ceiling: Effective starter with some Pro Bowls along the way. NFL Floor: Turnover prone, below average starter.
It seems that Griffin is not anywhere near Luck according to the person doing the writeup. This seems to follow what I've been thinking, but the level of Kool-Aid around here is almost biblical, so I was wondering if I am being led astray.
National Football Post: The Colts land the top QB prospect and top overall prospect. Luck possesses the skills to not only mature into a franchise quarterback, but potentially one of the best in the league. He will make everyone around him better and put his team in position for a number of Super Bowls. NFL ceiling: Future All Pro and Super Bowl winning QB. NFL floor: Solid franchise quarterback.
Do you agree with the evaluations?
Yes (20 votes)
No (102 votes)
Chupacabra (51 votes)
173 total votes