If The Redskins Sign Peyton, There Will Be No Saturday

but Monty is just not a very good football player. Saturday would be an upgrade and we could still draft a Molk, who could then replace him in a year or two.

Just to entertain the thought of bringing someones else garbage to our team ? He might be a decent QB but to bring him here is about the stupiest thing this team could ever do . If we brought him here 5 years ago i say ok but bring him here after a neck problem and only if we are lucky for 2 or 3 years , this would screw this team up for years to come . If dan synder allows this stupidity to happen he should sell this team to someone who cares about this team .
Rebuild from the draft not by getting old garbage from other teams to come here and freakin retire .

Tom brady wins this super bowl he will be tied with terry bradshaw and joe montana for most super bowl wins.

Why can’t we sign Peyton and continue to rebuild the right way?? He would allow us to be competitive during the rebuild. Last time this post was up UK was saying if we sign Peyton than we have to get Saturday and Wayne with it so this post throws that out the window. So why can’t we do both??

What has peyton manning done ? WOW 1 super bowl .

I will say that but as far as being better than tom brady your crazy . Tom brady has been to 5 super bowls in 10 years can peyton manning say that ?I think not , peyton manning was living off his dads name thats all .

You will set this team back years if you brought in peyton manning . Sure waste 28 millions and sign him for a few years then watch him screw this team up and retire or get hurt before his contracts up

HMMMMM tom brady 5 peyton how many ?

Wheres all the peyton fans to argue their points again ?

Its all about the RING and even though marino might be good he never got a RING , so if you can not win it all then your not that good .

Be realistic now.. Jim McMahon is better than Dan Marino?? Trent Dilfer is better than Dan Marino?? But I’m with you on Brady better than Manning. Brady could be the best ever!

Plusses

• Redskins will have an elite QB for the next 2 to 5 years.
• Leadership for the young guys
• Allows Redskins to keep all draft picks
• Can focus on rebuilding OL, WR, DB, and ILB via the draft this year
• The skins may be able to be more strategic and opportunistic next year or the year after in drafting his replacement

Minuses
• Durability, can he keep playing at an elite level for at least 2 years. Can he remain healthy?
• Cost, cap implications?
• Will we need to bring in Saturday, Wayne etc? Is that a good or bad thing?
• Can he get along with Shanny & son?

Even though part of me REALLY wants to see us get that kind of QB. But is he really healthy and if so how many more years does he really have in him? Maybe 3?

and this thread almost impossible to navigate

he’ll get that arm back to 95%, or not play.

some of your logical reason don’t float

WILL NOT play in the same division as his brother…that is the silliest reason for him not to come here. That will not be an issue

Arizona has a shot at a Super Bowl? San Fran has good WRs? What makes you think San Fran wants him?

Not only are you at nearly 200 comments on a Jeff Saturday post, but this has been one of the most entertaining things I’ve ever read. At times it reads like a Mel Brooks movie.

Question, why do people think Rgiii will be a good QB in the NFL? Who is he going to be like Michael Vick? Look at their college numbers and ability numbers. Isn’t it going out on a limb picking up a QB like him who doesn’t match anyone who ever won a superbowl? When Vick came out it was talked about, not so much with Newton maybe times are changing and I didn’t notice. Funny how they changed without any S.B. victories.

About Manning, at 60% he’s probably better than most and we don’t really risk anything, no draft picks, at least that matter much. Let’s say next year with manning we pick 16 to 30 without we could pick at 5 to 15. I like to win but who really knows.

pretty simple actually if you have younger brothers or a younger brother than you should understand and for those that don’t; brothers compete yes but not usually in public. There is no way he is going to come and play his bro twice a year. Also if the colts believe they can get healthy years out of him they would want to keep him I think.

Hmmm what does this mean? Guess San D. just sucks.

talk to you guys later hope this helped.