For the record, i like both guys. These guys are MEN in every sense of the word. High character, intelligent, hard-working gentlemen who can represent a franchise. With that said, lets compare the numbers.
RG3 in 2011(Primarily in Spread Offense)
267 Completions out of 369 attempts with a 72.4% completion rate
3998 yards with a 10.9 yards per pass average
36 touchdowns thrown with 6 passes being intercepted
192.3 QB Rating
Sacked 23 times
MATT BARKLEY in 2011(Primarily Under Center)
308 completions out of 446 attempts with a 69.1% completion rate
3528 yards with a 7.9 yards per pass average
39 touchdowns thrown with 7 passes intercepted
161.2 QB Rating
Sacked 8 times
vs. Oklahoma: 21-34 for 479 yards, 5 touchdowns and 0 interceptions
MATT BARKLEY-Signature Performance
@ Oregon: 26-34 for 323 yards, 4 touchdowns and 1 interception
Basically it comes down to who would be best for the system the Shanny's run. In my honest opinion, i think Barkley is the better FIT FOR THE SYSTEM. Barkley has played mostly in a pro style system. I'm not hating on the spread offense. Hell Look at Cam Newton and Andy Dalton. But i'm not the GM. lol Its a nice debate to have, so have it in the comment section.
Is there another QB that has your interest besides RG3 and Matt Barkley?
Yes (53 votes)
No (73 votes)
126 total votes