For the record, i like both guys. These guys are MEN in every sense of the word. High character, intelligent, hard-working gentlemen who can represent a franchise. With that said, lets compare the numbers.

RG3 in 2011(Primarily in Spread Offense)

267 Completions out of 369 attempts with a 72.4% completion rate

3998 yards with a 10.9 yards per pass average

36 touchdowns thrown with 6 passes being intercepted

192.3 QB Rating

Sacked 23 times

MATT BARKLEY in 2011(Primarily Under Center)

308 completions out of 446 attempts with a 69.1% completion rate

3528 yards with a 7.9 yards per pass average

39 touchdowns thrown with 7 passes intercepted

161.2 QB Rating

Sacked 8 times

RG3-Signature Performance

vs. Oklahoma: 21-34 for 479 yards, 5 touchdowns and 0 interceptions

MATT BARKLEY-Signature Performance

@ Oregon: 26-34 for 323 yards, 4 touchdowns and 1 interception

My Oberservation

Basically it comes down to who would be best for the system the Shanny's run. In my honest opinion, i think Barkley is the better FIT FOR THE SYSTEM. Barkley has played mostly in a pro style system. I'm not hating on the spread offense. Hell Look at Cam Newton and Andy Dalton. But i'm not the GM. lol Its a nice debate to have, so have it in the comment section.