Rex Grossman has been pretty much what we expected, an efficient game manager at times & a TO waiting to happen at others. His decision making at critical times has been poor on a couple of occasions but he has led the Skins to a 3 & 1 record & IMHO he looked his best against the toughest team we have played this year, the Giants. Our offensive line is still a liability against the better pass rushing teams & Beck is much more of a mobile QB than Grossman. Beck also seems to have a stronger arm altho on a few occasions, when Rex had the time & room to step into his throws he was able to wing it down the field. By making the switch of Beck & Grossman at this point we would be making a decision that we probably would be stuck with for the rest of the season (& by that I mean that by switching the two, we show a lack of faith in Grossman so that it would be tough to switch back if Beck falters).
I am curious how the rest of Hogs Haven feel about replacing Grossman with Beck during our bye week.
For my part, I am against a change. I think that the decision that was made at the end of pre-season was the correct one, that Rex Grossman gives us the best chance to win & once that decision was made that our coaching staff should stick with it. I think that a lot of Grossmans problems have been because of the offensive line & that if our QB had more time he would be playing better.
Who should be the QB when the Skins play the Eagles ??
John Beck (67 votes)
Rex Grossman (111 votes)
Parks need to post that pic of a guy beating a dead horse (29 votes)
207 total votes