Pour Some Sugar On Me - Week One Edition: Time to Stay Positive
Unlike my colleague Kevin, I am not ready to throw in the towel on this season. What kind of fan does that anyway after one week? (Answer at the bottom of the post.)
Did I think the Redskins could beat the Giants going into that game Sunday? Of course I did.
Do I think the Giants are the better team after Week One? I am compelled to believe that today after the Redskins' loss.
Ah, but there is this--it is Week One. The Giants are the better team right now. Right now. The difference between these two teams might be more than the 6 points the score indicated, but the Giants are considered the class of the NFC. If the Redskins can improve in areas that they clearly need to work on as the season progresses, it is possible that we aren't as bad off as we feel today. I am not just trying to blow smoke up your 5-hole either. It is a long season and a lot can happen. Or not happen. Like these two plays which, to me, rank right up there as the two plays that you would think we could eliminate from future contests, given the Redskin players involved.
1) 2nd and 8, ball on NYG 42, 8:30 left in 1st half - Jason Campbell throws up the right sideline for Santana Moss and is intercepted by Webster. First of all, the obvious: did anyone else think JC might have been able to get the 1st down by running? I did. Tough to say for sure of course. Secondly, he wasn't just over the line of scrimmage...he was WAY over, right? Like at least a yard and a half, maybe 2 yards? The penalty would have been five yards and loss of down, meaning 3rd and 13 from the NYG 47. Instead, Santana Moss gets beaten to the ball by Webster, who makes an incredible play to come down with the INT. Did anyone else think Santana Moss had something to do with that pickle? I thought he could have done more at the end of the play, either by doing a better job of coming back for the ball or by keeping Webster from coming down with the ball. To be fair, Webster came from behind him to make the play, but it just seemed like Moss slowed up at the last second and that was enough for Webster to be able to get in and make the play.
2) 1st and 10, ball on WASH 48, 2:29 left in the first half - Osi Umenyiora beats Chris Samuels for the sack, forced fumble, and fumble recovery that leads to Osi running in the touchdown that put the Giants up 17-0.
Ugh. Despite the fact that we were down 10-0 when this drive began, you got the feeling that if the Skins could score before the half, momentum could start shifting. The previous play was a 3rd and 8 that we converted when JC found Randle El for 9 yards in the middle of the field. I know I was watching and thinking that JC was looking a bit more comfortable on this drive. i would love to hear some of your opinions of this play by Samuels. He got beaten badly. I know it was just one play, but it was a HUGE play. The sack was bad enough. The fumble was that much worse. The fact that Osi then took it the other way for 6 was simply nad-pummeling.
These two first half plays killed us in my opinion. We outscored the Giants 10-6 in the second half. In the first half, the outcomes of either one of these drives (both at or near midfield) could have netted the Redskins points that very well could have re-shaped the final result. There were more pivotal plays in the game than these two, but to me, these are the two stuck in my brain.
Ten Yard Fight-10 Chances to Make One Good Point
Unlike the preseason, I won't be doing wrap-ups of every game. You can get that by watching any one of the seven billion re-runs of Sportscenter between now and Friday. Besides, most of you watched the games anyway, unlike the preseason, when I was one of the few retards who decided to watch all of the games. In this week's ten observations, I will man up where I was wrong going into the season opener, and then I will tout the preseason analysis I made that was right on the money. First, where I was wrong (after the jump):
1) Okay, so Jermichael Finley wasn't the world-beater in week one that I promised you. He had one catch for 6 yards. In a game where every yard came at a premium, I would have thought he would be targeted more than once. I was wrong.
2) Over at SBNation.com, the brand new sports website that was launched last Thursday, a certain writer for their Fantasy Football front page compared the Tampa Bay Buccaneers offense to "a turd wrapped in a dirty tissue stuffed inside a bag of vomit." Well, I may have been a bit harsh. Maybe leave out the dirty tissue. You can see my Weekly Mailbag column every Wednesday and my Start 'Em/Sit 'Em column every Friday, written under the pen name of 'Ken Meringolo'.
3) Speaking of my awful fantasy advice, I implored fantasy owners to consider starting Malcolm Kelly as a gamble pick in a game where the Giants would eliminate Santana Moss. Holy crap! I have to do better. Though to be fair, I got the part about Santana Moss being eliminated right.
4) I thought Reggie Bush would be a far bigger factor on the ground than his 2.0 yards per carry. With Pierre Thomas out, Reggie Bush was a guy I figured would explode. I was wrong.
5) All of my Friday Night "Mights" proved to be off, I guess. For all of you out there raining on me for bad "predictions", keep in mind that first and foremost, these "mights" pre-suppose a victory. And they will be a mainstay for the season. (I hope I won't go 0-5 very often!)
Now, for the last five, I get to say,
"I've been telling you all preseason that..."
6) ...Mark Sanchez is ready to play and win now. He did not look like a rookie against the Texans.
7) ...The Packers' defense is for real. Jay Cutler is no slouch. Matt Forte is no slouch. The Packers got after them on Sunday night. Those linebackers were everywhere, and the secondary made Jay Cutler pay for overestimating his ability to put the ball in a tight spot with double-, triple-, and even quadruple-coverage.
8a) ...Kurt Warner has been lacking something this summer. He certainly has not found his rhythm in the offense yet for the 2009 season. He did not look horrible but completing less than 60% of his passes for less than 300 yards and two interceptions that left him with a 67.2 passer rating is not what we have come to expect from Warner. I bet a lot of folks in knockout/suicide pools were out after one week yesterday, thanks to the Cards dropping that game to the 49ers.
8b) ...Jake Delhomme looks like he is done. He didn't look good in August, and he looked even worse in the opener. Reminded me A LOT of the guy who had a horrendous playoff performance last year.
9) ...Drew Brees is in a universe all to himself. OK, so this was no great prediction. Of course, the Lions are the Lions, but Brees looks like he is on a Hall of Fame case-making kind of year. That team needs to find the playoffs for him to really get on the road to Canton, but his numbers are going to be off the charts again this year.
10) ...Mike Singletary was going to get the most out of this team. Shaun Hill had about 200 yards passing. Frank Gore had 30 yards rushing. The defense held when it had to and Shaun Hill came through in the 4th quarter. Singletary was working his sideline in the 4th quarter--did you see that? Either the Cardinals are a lot worse than we thought they were, or the 49ers have a real shot at making noise in the NFC West this year. Remember last year when there were THREE 2-7 teams in the NFC West? That won't happen again this year.
MNF) Can someone please tell me how Leodis McKelvin thought it was a good idea to bring out the kickoff with 2 minutes remaining in their game against the Patriots? With three minutes to go in the 1st quarter, the Oakland Raiders look like they are punching Norv Turner in the balls. So great.
Give Me the Numbers, STAT!
In this space each week we will look at stats for both the Redskins as well as team and player stat rankings around the league. By tracking these throughout the season, we hope to offer explanations and analysis as to how our team is doing as well as other trends in the league.
Last season, the Giants averaged 5.0 yards per carry. Brandon Jacobs averaged 5.0 yards per carry. Yesterday, the Giants averaged 3.3 yards per carry, and Jacobs 2.9 yards per carry. Consider also that the Giants led the league in rushing yards per carry (all stats from nfl.com.) A new season, a new look, a new slate for all teams--I get it. To properly measure that performance, we will need to see how the Giants run on their next couple of opponents. I am pretty sure they will fare better against other opponents.
Of the 28 teams that had completed their games by Monday morning, the Redskins ranked 19th in total defense (19th against the run and 18th against the pass.) One sack and one interception also put is in the bottom quarter of defenses. So let's set some expectations. We have some opponents coming up that are not in the same class as the New York Giants. Based on this, I am looking for our defense to put itself squarely on the map. If we don't see our ranking rise in the next two weeks, we will know that something is dreadfully wrong.
Finally, can we stop already with the negativity after one game? It would have been great to win on the road in the first week against the Giants. But nobody had that game circled as a certain win. As far as losses go, it was ugly at points, yet there were plenty of moments to cheer about, as noted by most of you yesterday in the recap comments section. What will define this team in the short-term is its ability to win the games it "should" win. Between now and when we hit the murderous portion of our schedule--if this team fancies itself a playoff team--they will have to do what every playoff team does: improve each week in team defense, overall offensive efficiency, and establish an identity that instills some fear in your opponents. It makes no sense to jump off the deep end calling for Zorn's ouster, or calling for Campbell to be benched. Come on. What kind of fan does that make you if you tuck tail and run after one loss? Answer: an Eagles fan.
You're better than that Redskins Nation.
49 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Nice use of the jump!
And I agree with pas, this reads much better than Kevin’s turd in a dirty tissue of an article.
haha
All fun and laughs. I might as well go for the trifecta and do a Sugar’s mom joke. Yea, I can understand the turd sandwich’s lash back. Right after I posted this I noticed the Fan Post asking for everyone to relax…so I knew I was in trouble then. It is true it is only week 1, but we look like the exact same team as last year. I don’t mind losing games…but there wasn’t much to get excited about offensively.
As Lloyd Christmas would say, “Harry…I’m so sick of being sick and tired.”
by Kevin Ewoldt on Sep 15, 2009 11:12 AM EDT up reply actions
You were at the game, so I will give you a ‘pass’ for now. There is nothing more depressing than going to a road game and losing….sucks big time. Plus your view of the game is skewd from being drunk and surrounded by midget fans. The performance was much better than the two nyg games last year….it was lackluster but totally winnable. We got run over last year and had no chance of winning either game. The two min offense looked great and we shut down the run well and had better pressure than last year (when eli had like ten secs to throw it). Playcalling still stinks and running right are still issues….but fixable with the rams and lions up next.
I think I’m going to the Skins-Panthers game, so hopefully I’ll be the polar opposite of Kevin after we dismantle Delhomme!
by Parks Smith on Sep 15, 2009 12:01 PM EDT up reply actions
Delhomme not
By then the panthers should have moved on to Feeley.
As much frustration as I had for the Redskins performance and coache’s play calling, I actually felt worse for the home town Panthers…it was pitiful and eagles did not play that well.
At least we aren't the Panthers...
and owe an aging and seemingly hapless QB $20 million bucks.
Wow…I guess though in the uncapped year next year it kind of doesn’t matter (unless it is your money).
Geez...
Well, hopefully my post tonight of the Giants game experience will win some love back. When the Skins went down 17-0…I just started taking pics of hot chicks.
You have a lot to live up to now
Sugar is now the People’s Champ
by Parks Smith on Sep 15, 2009 10:21 AM EDT up reply actions
And for the record...
I’m not throwing in the towel….I’m just stating what I think Snyderrato will do. (Fire Zorn and JC).
I’m fed up with not having a team I can ride the lows with…guess that didn’t come through.
On the other hand....
Being critical does not = being a bad fan. It was all out there for everyone to see. How you react to it is your issue. My 2 biggest issues were a lack of an attack mode on O (play not to win mentality) and we started this season the same way we ended last season – no improvement on O despite some reasonable expectations to the contrary. I’m not throwing in the towel. I’m just pissed. Big difference.
riding the lows is one thing
But if Zorn and Campbell end up with a worse record say 6-10 or 7-9, do you ride it out another year or does the fan want the owner to make a change. I would like to see a change which will work.
doesn't matter
what the fan wants. “The owner” will make the change regardless. BUT, to answer your question – YES, I would want a change. I’m just not sure what we’d be changing to. This was Snyder and Cerrato’s hand picked MAN. If Zorn works out, Snyder’s a genius. If he doesn’t, then what? Do you “hand pick” another guy? Do you go for a retread/minor league coach like Fassel? Do you throw the BIG bucks at Cowher, then watch him come here to collect a paycheck with his heart not really into it? I’m sure, just like most everyone else is, that Shanahan will be the first choice. But how good a choice will he be? He will want total control first of all. I know that sounds enticing with the debacle we have upstairs now, but is it really? Shanahan wasn’t exactly making sound decisions with the Broncos before he got canned. In fact, it seems the only team he could come out ahead of in a trade is us. So how would that work if he’s here? Nope, I don’t want Shanahan. Right now, I want Zorn. Because I want to win this year. If not Zorn next year, who do I want? I’ll tell ya………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
DANNY SMITH!!!! – since he’s the only one who seems to have balls on the coaching staff right now.
Have your seen our Special Teams the last couple years?
Maybe its a lack of depth and poor ST players (in which case the blame falls on the FO) but I think Danny Smith has failed to get his Teams to be consistent, disciplined, and productive and it has cost us a few games.
well being a Redskin fan
I happily swing back and forth between both of the articles and find the bits that suit me. I sometimes wonder if it means that I have to be a manic depressive just to be a ‘Skins fan. However, I want to see some urgency out of the club and especially from Campbell, now I know that one man’s urgency may be another fella’s panic, but I think most of you get me on this in that Jason doesn’t appear to have much inner fire, Or else he’s keeping all of his emotions in check. I stated earlier in another recap thread that I simply wonder if Zorn gets it. Gints only dress so many DB’s and where are the 4 and 5 receiver sets? Where are the screen passes? Sure ARE and Cooley had decent games on quick hitters but I would have liked to have seen more attempts to attack them rather than taking what was given. Too many passes behind the line of scrimmage imho.
As for McKelvin, I thought the idea was good, but the lack of knowledge that they were gonna stand him up and attempt to strip him obviously never came to mind. Just run it up and fall down for cryin out loud.
I used to be disgusted, now I try to be amused....
I'm trying to stay positive but the players are not the main problem....
The play calling was absolutely horrific on sunday. On the second offensive play of the game they run a reverse against arguably the best defensive line in football. Yeah and I know Randle-El should have just thrown the ball away but is still doesn’t change the play call. This is the kind of play that needs to be set up throughout the course of the game not on the second offensive snap. Then there was the three and out inside their own ten yard line, you remember three straight runs. Whether Jim Zorn knows this or not this a huge confidence killer for Jason Campbell and it shows how little of faith he has in his starting QB. Then there was the WR screen to Santana on second and goal and this one had me out of my chair and yelling at the television. The ball was on the five yard line and I was just outraged by that play call. How about a fade to Malcolm or Marko. I understand Marko’s a rookie but from what I saw in the presason he knows how to run a fade route and he can go up a get the ball. There’s more plays that I could list but I don’t have the time. I will stay positive but the play calling has to improve big time.
You nailed it
You have to set up a play like that. It was a dubious call at best. Later in the game, if that play fails and Randle El gets sacked, at least you can feel like you set it up and took your shot. On the second play of the game, it feels forced. I didn’t get it.
Great write up
Have the Redskins improved this season? At this point I say yes.
Have the Redskins improved to the point that they are better than the Giants? I’d have to say no.
That’s what I got out of Sundays game. The Giants have a way of making good offenses look BAD. Let’s not judge the offense yet.
what improvements did you see Sunday?
Outside of ARE doing great in the slot, I can’t really think of any.
Pass protection was better I guess, but the run blocking was worse, so it’s a wash, IMO
Osi Umenyiora beats Chris Samuels for the sack… i would love to hear some of your opinions of this play by Samuels. He got beaten badly.
Samuels kept Osi on the outside leaving a HUGE pocket for JC to step into. I’m not sure what else Samuels could do there except turn around and shove JC up where he should have been.
I was getting ready
To say something about that. Zorn was on Comcast Sportsnet yesterday and said that play was completely Campbell’s fault. Zorn said something like “alls he had to do was step up into the pocket and throw” during the interview. He ended up yelling at Campbell when we went to the sidelines, which is understandable since stepping up into the pocket is something so fundamental and basic, and more importantly something that Zorn has taught Campbell to do.
Hence why I employ the pinions of the Hogs Haven faithful
I think the point still remains valid: it was a play that can be prevented in the future by better individual effort. In this case, I will defer to the majority and say it is JC that needs to step it up in this situation down the road.
I wonder...
If Mark Sanchez or Jay Cutler would have stepped up in to the pocket, or at least not have held on to the ball as if it were glued to the palm of his hand.
Playcalling
A reverse pass after CP just ripped off 34 yards on the ground????!? Jim Zorn is up to his old tricks.
I disagree
sure it was a fine place to do it. But I don’t like having a WR attempt the first pass of the QB’s “make or break” season.
I agree, kinda
If ARE completed that pass for positive yardage, or if he even just threw it away, I seriously doubt that any of us would be talking about it right now. However, I don’t see why Zorn would call that play right after a 34 yard run by CP.
That is the point
The first game of the season is about seeing where the team is at and to improve the team for the future.
We should not be relying on trick plays the second play of the season.
What Zorn was saying was, I do not think we can beat your defense after 1 play, so we will resort to trying to trick you
Even if it went for a TD, it was still the wrong play. If we wanted to make a statement, have Campbell try to complete a 20 yd pass
I think the point is to win the game
and a trick play isn’t a bad call there, after the defense is deflated from a big run, and we have the ball on their side of the field.
I don’t think the significance of it being the 2nd play of the season should effect the play call one way or the other.
I would readily
agree with you in any other instance. But, again, everyone knows Campbell will be under the microscope this year. And there’s every reason to believe his confidence is very low and needs lifted fast. It’s also been noted many times that he is much better when he is able to get into a rhythm early. All this points to giving him the 1st pass OF THE SEASON. I’m all for taking a chance. But why not take one with Malcolm and/or Devin running long and have JC air it out for his 1st throw. You know he’s been dying to do it for 3 years now. Can you imagine where his confidence would be if he connected on a bomb with his first throw of the season? And if he doesn’t connect then, hey, it’s 2nd and 10. Move on.
Man, this stuff comes so easy to me. I think I might be a genius. Why aren’t I calling plays for the Skins? And they said my 380 SAT score would get me nowhere.
Sorry to be down!
All I want is for some offense! If you exclude the last TD drive, we were miserable: Clinton couldn’t run, Jason continues to be a good #3 QB if he was in the Canadian league, and where is Zorn’s play calling coming from? The Giants underneath secondary is weak, but we didn’t exploit it. The Giants d-line was great and we helped prove we couldnt run more than 2 yards against it. JC just isn’t improving and I agree with the comment above: he seems to have zero fire in his gut. He gets a great paycheck for being an occasional runner and an absolutely poor field general. I just knew when Dan went down to 2 QBs that something big was about to happen. It did: Jason still played the whole game poorly. How long has it been since the Redskins had a really good QB? If we can spend $40 Mil for Hainsworth (and he is worth it) why can’t we find a QB that can lead AND throw. Coach you’re billed as an offensive coach and I must admit I have confidence you won’t continue to be this offensive to the game. Also quit making the “everything is wonderful” talks. It isn’t! Yes, we’ll beat the Rams but so could Bowie State.
Rocky Mac
Anybody else think this guy isn’t living up to his expectations?
a player with a history of knee injuries
who we gave up multiple draft picks for?
another quality move by Dan Snyder

by 




















