Hogs Haven: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: RSL Soapbox for Real Salt Lake Fans!

Portis: Still the Choice for MVP

It's worth spending a couple of moments to preempt the inevitable discussion of Adrian Peterson as this year's NFL MVP, or even the league's best running back. It's true, after his fine performance against the Packers yesterday, Peterson now leads in one important category: rushing yards. An impressive feat to be sure. But how do his numbers stack up to other runningbacks around the league Clinton Portis?

Well, let's go back to those rushing yards. Peterson has carried the ball 206 times for 1,015 yards (4.927 yards per carry); Portis, 200 for 995 yards (4.975 yards per carry). Most sports websites will round Peterson's down to 4.9 and Portis's up to 5.0, but the difference is only an extra 1.72 inches per carry for Portis, not statistically significant at any reasonable sensitivity level, even when ignoring potential measurement error effects (officials spotting the ball imprecisely). Bottom line, Peterson rushed for 20 more yards on 6 more carries. Ho hum. Point reluctantly goes to Peterson, but only so the end tally appears somewhat impartial.

Touchdowns: 7 to 7. ...Next.

Fumbles: Peterson has 4, including 3 recovered by the opposing defense; Portis has 1, also lost. Point goes to CP.

Versatility: Both players have made minor contributions in the passing game. Portis's 150 yards top Peterson's 98, and actually put him over the top when it comes to total yards (1,145 to 1,113). Oh, and "not everyone knows this, but Portis is the best pass protecting RB blocker in the league." Point goes to CP.

Match-ups - the coup de grâce. I don't know of a single coherent argument that the NFC North is as tough of a division as the NFC East, so the previous comparisons greatly benefit Peterson (although not to the same extent as comparing Babe Ruth to others like Hank Aaron). So let's set aside every game these two backs have played - except for their shared opponents:

Mvpwatch_medium

Clinton Portis: 45 rushing attempts for 222 yards and 2 touchdowns, with no fumbles. Peterson: 46 rushing attempts for 143 yards, no touchdowns, and 2 fumbles lost. Point goes to CP.

Final Tally: Portis 3, Peterson 1.

0 recs  |  Comment 1 comment |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

A good analysis

But Portis is going to need a bunch of big games in order to actually gain MVP. Don’t discount the play of Kurt Warner in Arizona, either, or Drew Brees in New Orleans.

MVP is definitely more than statistics, and I believe that Portis is the player who matters more to his team — he always puts his team on his shoulders. He will need to do that for the remainder of the season, as he usually does, to wrap up the MVP award.

A few big games, especially against a team like Dallas which everyone will be watching, will put Portis back at #1.

by mmford10 on Nov 10, 2008 5:30 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Media Requests please email hogshaven@gmail.com
Start posting about the Redskins »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Sidney-harbour-australia_small
Positivity week!!!
Small
Cerrato Owes Campbell an Apology...And I Have Written It

Recent FanPosts

Small
Friday Fandomonium
Sidney-harbour-australia_small
Skins History
Skinsdallas_small
We have a player of the week......
Cooley_small
COWGIRLS hate WEEK!!!!!
Img_1768_small
Supreme Court Refuses to Hear Redskins Name Case
Small
So this is what winning feels like. I remember now!
Lavarr_small
My Dream Overhaul
Bottleboyavatar_small
do you think somebody might be using a voodoo doll?
Small
Joe Bugel is no E. F. Hutton ...

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Bolts From The Blue
Week 11 Injury Report: SD @ DEN
Mobile Live
Eagles shuffle linebackers again
Mobile Live
The VRR: Redskins (3-6) @ Cowboys (6-3)

SPONSORS


Managers

Superbowl_small KevinE

Riggins_small Ken Meringolo

H2_logo_b_small Sugar

Authors

Hogshaven_small Skin Patrol